On Sale At buildawatergarden.com!

Old Judge Cards


1887 Old Judge N172 MIKE DORGAN PSA 2 G New York Giants Vintage Baseball Card

$159.95


1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge Joe Dimaggio AUTO BGS Authentic Autograph (RM)

$75.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Dick Johnston Boston PSA

$129.99


1888 Goodwin & Co, Old Judge Cabinet Die Cut Box Top/Redemption Piece

$65.00


1887 N172 Old Judge #191-1 Jack Glasscock Indianapolis Ball IN Hand SGC

$149.99


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE JACK McGEACHY PSA 3

$113.50


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE JACK FARRELL PSA 2

$158.27


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BOBBY LOWE PSA 1.5

$129.27


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE MARK BALDWIN PSA 3 MK

$81.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE RIP VAN HALTREN PSA 1

$115.50


1887 N172 Old Judge JACK GLASSCOCK SGC 20 1.5 FR Lean on Bat, Indpls.Stamp Back!

$279.99


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE JOHN CLARKSON PSA 1 MK

$501.11


N172 OLD JUDGE TYPE REPRINT BASEBALL CARD SET SERIES 2

$13.95


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE JIM WHITNEY PSA 1

$43.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE LEON VIAU PSA 1.5 MK

$81.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DANNY RCHARDSON PSA 3

$107.50


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BILL FARMER PSA 1MK

$76.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes Baseball Card - Lot Set of 2  Richardson - Signed

$300.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE SCOTT STRATTON PSA 3

$158.27


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE YANK ROBINSON PSA 3

$41.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE LITTLE NICK NICOL PSA 3

$89.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE GUS KROCK PSA 3

$58.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE SHORTY FULLER PSA 1.5

$56.00


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE STEPHEN TOOLE PSA 3

$54.00


N172 OLD JUDGE TYPE REPRINT BASEBALL CARD SET SERIES 1

$13.95


⚾️The Photographic Baseball Cards of Goodwin & Co 1886-1890-Old Judge - New

$59.99


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE FRED PFEFFER PSA 1

$46.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Dell Darling Catch, Hands Chin High Chicago PSA

$129.99


1888 Old Judge N172 #397-1 Harry Sage Toledo SGC Grade 3

$1,275.00


1887 N172 Old Judge - Farrar - Philadelphia - SGC 20

$169.50


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE FRANK DWYER PSA 2

$39.00


1887 N172 Old Judge - Gillespie - New York - SGC 10

$168.50


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE SAM THOMPSON PSA 3

$1,025.00


1887 N172 Old Judge Sid Farrar Stooping To Fielder Grounder Philadelphia PSA

$109.99


1887 N172 OLD JUDGE ELTON CHAMBERLAIN PSA 2

$46.45


Justin Verlander 2005 ROOKIE CARD Upper Deck Origins OLD JUDGE RC Baseball ASTRO

$18.00


1887 Old Judge N172 Mike Dorgan

$133.50


1889 N172 OLD JUDGE - Al Mays - Hands Chest High PSA 2 Good - Columbus Solons

$149.00